Yoga and the Problem with Polyvagal Theory

By Kristine Kaoverii Weber | June 28, 2025

COMMENTS

a stick figure graphic of polyvagal theory

I first learned about polyvagal theory (PVT) 15 years ago at a trauma workshop held at a suburban home on a tree-lined street in Alexandria, Virginia. The presenter explained that dividing the autonomic nervous system into sympathetic and parasympathetic – which explained why we fight or flight when threated – was not entirely sufficient. Rather, a third evolutionarily relevant structure, the older, dorsal part of the vagus nerve, had been theorized by neuroscientist Stephen Porges to be responsible for the freeze response.

This new understanding would help therapists be able to support their clients in putting the shattered pieces of their lives back together after trauma, coming out of the freeze response, moving forward, and healing. I remember being blown away by Porges’ genius – this new theory was incredible.

But, because of my yoga background, I also knew it could never be the holy grail – because the vagus nerve is, well… it’s just a nerve.

And human beings are much more than nerves or nervous systems – we are exquisitely complex, vibrational-field producing and sensing, mind-body-spirit entities with complicated needs, desires and dreams – and complicated ways of healing. And, while many interventions can be helpful in our processes, the solutions to our problems will never be found in a mechanical device, somatic movement, breathwork, or massage technique aimed at activating one single nerve.

Since human beings are more than one nerve, then a hyperfocus on PVT can be a distraction from our process of self-understanding. Regulating the nervous system is great (I mean obviously I believe that, it’s a key focus of my work). I’m not saying PVT is wrong, what I’m saying is don’t let go of everything else you know to be true about healing through yoga. Many of the techniques that have emerged in this past decade to help increase vagal tone are somatic interventions derived from yoga practices.

There is a higher reason for learning to heal trauma and regulate the nervous system. Humans need to regulate so that we can examine, explore, and actualize our deeper potential, and realize who we truly are – which is the goal of yoga.

When we focus on a nerve without the context of human purpose, or without situating it within the broader context of cosmology and ontology, then we lose our way. PVT is not the map. Not externally, and not internally. It is simply a lovely feature of the map, but it’s not the map itself, it doesn’t explain the whole point of being human, it doesn’t point us to how to be human, it doesn’t give us a sense of meaning and purpose in our lives.

But yoga philosophy does.

Because of the western worldview, we are trained to seek simple, reductive solutions – a pill, a theory, a technique, a diet, or a silver bullet that will solve the problem quickly.

But human beings are complicated, and so are our problems. So anything we want to solve is going to have to be addressed from a systems solution that understands who we are as human beings and how we heal. It’s going to be complex, it’s going to take time, and it’s probably going to be hard (although anything meaningful usually is and real healing is always worth the effort and energy).

a person meditating in a chakra

Various psychotherapy leaders have been using yoga in their techniques for at least a century. And over the past decade or so, many new methods specifically aimed at vagal toning have emerged – which are often yogic techniques that have been rejigged and repackaged.

Therapists who sprinkle in relaxation techniques at the end of their therapy session, recommend “Navy Seal square breathing,” or offer meditations to increase feelings of safety could greatly benefit from studying and learning about the whole systems of yoga from where these techniques have emerged, and the philosophy that underpins it.

For me, as a yoga teacher, trainer, and therapist, I find having newly refurbished techniques sold back to me particularly frustrating.  And it happens all the time.

  • “Here are some havening techniques to add to your ‘yoga flows’”
  • “Here is some vagal ear massage to do before shavasana”
  • “Here’s a humming breath to stimulate your vagus nerve”
  • “Add a safe feeling ‘Glimmer’ meditation at the end of your practice”

Just like Chinese Medicine, Chiropractic, Psychotherapy, Herbalism, or Homeopathy, Yoga Therapy is a system. We have frameworks for treatment, health promotion, prevention, and recovery. We use the panchamaya koshas, the chakras, the gunas, the doshas, and principles for therapeutic sequencing (which should not be confused with choreographed fitness “flows”) to achieve therapeutic goals.

Because so many of our techniques are so user-friendly and low risk and because we have not fully explained our profession and scope – it's really easy to take them out of context and use them in all sorts of ways – but it's a problem. It waters down our work, it shoves us back into the fitness box, it makes the public clueless about our existence.

I invite therapists and health care professionals to study our frameworks, do our practices, resist the urge to sprinkle in a little yoga here and there in your sessions until you understand it more deeply, and to unlearn some of the reductive, scientific materialist thinking that is so deeply embedded in our culture.

I invite yoga professionals to think about PVT as an asset to our profession that can help us better explain the beauty and power of what we do, and to contextualize it, so that we don't allow it to be another western innovation siphoning wisdom out of the yoga tradition.

 

Please check out my free eBook: Work Your Breath: for Energy, Focus, or Rest

CHAIR YOGA FOR YOUR BRAIN & NERVOUS SYSTEM

SUBTLE® YOGA FOR ENHANCING TRAUMA RECOVERY

Five Ways Yogic Meditation Benefits Your Brain – eBook

QUESTIONS?

We would love to hear from you!

    Please wait while comments are loading...

    SUBTLE YOGA HAS SO MUCH TO OFFER!

    Sign up for updates, events, and blog.

    You have Successfully Subscribed!