What's Better for Brain Health - Hard Exercise or Slow Yoga?
By Kristine Kaoverii Weber | January 24, 2025

Q: My husband is an athlete and is training for a race next month. He has been listening to podcasts about the cognitive benefits of HIIT and interval training. He certainly seems mentally sharper when he trains compared to rest months. There seems to be a lot of opinions about what boosts brain function. My question is how does slowing movement down enhance brain function compared to pushing harder. Love to hear your thoughts.
This is a question that I’ve been interested in for many years so I’m happy to share some thoughts.
Everyone is different and people need different things at different times in their lives. There is ample evidence that hard exercise is healthful, for many reasons, and we all know what those are including cardiovascular, metabolic, longevity, and brain benefits. And, over the past few years there's been a, shall we say, steroidal uptick in the Silicon Valley podcaster trend of promoting extreme athleticism and hard exercise.
Which is fine, until it isn’t.
There are plenty of risks involved in intense exercise including injuries that can be problematic later in life. My father was a sprinter and an all-American football player in high school and college. He was a stellar athlete. But he also sustained many injuries and TBIs, and now, 60+ years later, he's riddled with arthritis, in a lot of pain, and struggles with mobility and mood issues. It’s sad to see what happens later in life to some people who were in top form as young athletes. To me, it seems a little like he was sacrificed like a gladiator when he was young. Nobody knew back then what the consequences would be of course, but we know now.
The other day, my husband went to buy running shoes and the trainer at the store asked him how old he was. He told him that he's 65. Then the guy said, "Yeah, we don't get a lot of older customers. Most people your age have stopped running because of their knees."
Of course everyone’s experience is different. Some athletes seem to be made of steel. And, as I said, everyone knows that exercise is definitely good for the brain. So, for me, the questions are: What is the risk? How much exercise is enough? Is is sustainable? The answers are going to depend on who you are, what your constitution is like, what you spend a lot of time doing, how your joints are holding up, and what your goals are.

Studies over the past few decades or so, including some interesting research from people who measure interoceptive awareness, suggest that slow, mindful movement has numerous benefits including reducing stress, regulating cortisol levels, improving metabolism, blood pressure, heart rate variability, fasting blood glucose, cholesterol, inflammation, and mental acuity - all of which contribute to improved brain health.
But there isn't as much research and it's not as out there in the public as the exercise research. Also, slow, mindful research crosses several fields - exercise, mindfulness, meditation, mental health and more - so it's a little harder to nail down. But, if you look at these studies collectively, many of the benefits of slow, mindful practices are similar to those of hard exercise and also may contribute to better brain health.
So, how can both of these things be true – that hard exercise as well as slow, mindful practices both benefit the brain – even though they seem like opposite endeavors?
I think one way to look at this is to begin by letting go of simplistic ideas about the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS). The ANS is responsible both for sympathetic activation (the fight or flight response), and parasympathetic activation (the rest and digest, tend and befriend, calm and connect, and freeze responses). Now, these responses are not antagonistic and they don't operate like a switch. We don’t turn on the sympathetic system and shut down the parasympathetic or vice versa. It’s a lot more nuanced than that. You can think about them more like partners in a dance - I need different amounts of each throughout my day - a little sympathetic activation gives my brain some focus and attention, and helps me hike up a hill, some parasympathetic action helps me chill out, concentrate, and sleep better. And being able to adapt to whatever situation I am in and respond appropriately is the sign of a healthy ANS and good resilience.
A healthy nervous system is one that can bounce easily between the sympathetic and parasympathetic without spilling over into the fight or flight response or ending up shut down, vegged out, or emotionally frozen. But, for many people, this balance is delicate and easily dysregulated.
Neuroscientist Dan Seigel talks about “The Window of Affect Tolerance.” We want to have a wide open window in order to be able to tolerate (and thrive in) all sorts of situations in life. In my opinion you open that window wider by engaging in many different types of activities - not just hard exercise.
The entirety of the ANS needs to be well maintained in order for us to function well. And, just like everything else in the body, it is not discrete, it’s intimately influenced by not only your physiology, but also by your mind, your behavior, habits, and relationships. Both faster exercise as well as slower, more mindful practices can help. But it’s nuanced and complex and you need to be honest with yourself about what the right combination of activities is for you. It's helpful to let go of the hype, go inside, and evaluate what you need - and yoga is great for helping you do just that.
Many elite athletes practice yoga, and not just for stretching, but for mindfulness, interoceptive skill building, and focus. According to the yoga tradition, less is more. There are stories of monks who sat for days and weeks in deep meditation, not moving, hardly breathing, who lived crazy long lives and who developed fantastically complex theories on the nature of reality, life, and the universe - in other words their brains worked quite well.

Human beings are meant to move and movement, in any form that you enjoy is good for you physically and mentally.
But human beings are also meant to think, ponder, explore the inner landscape, and connect to our higher selves. Slow movement, and seated breathing and meditation practices are helpful for that. I think most people need a combination of both, and we need to tailor the practices to suit the needs and the goals of each person.
Please check out my free ebook, 5 Ways Yogic Meditation Changes Your Brain.
CHAIR YOGA FOR YOUR BRAIN & NERVOUS SYSTEM
SUBTLE® YOGA FOR ENHANCING TRAUMA RECOVERY
Five Ways Yogic Meditation Benefits Your Brain – eBook
QUESTIONS?
We would love to hear from you!
Please wait while comments are loading...



I recommend a book called “why does it still hurt?” by Paul biegler. He researches and explores pain and dives into neuroplasticity, exercise methods, the non-requirement for surgeries and how the mind can hypnotised or educated to not experience or expect pain. I feel the exercise question you talk about is addressed within these illuminating pages.
yes really good point about CP or persistent pain. Slow, mindful movement is a key element in an overall pain reduction strategy. Research shows that education about CP is also very helpful for reducing it.
“we don’t get a lot of older customers. Most people your age have stopped running because of their knees.” I know this well, have been running since I was a junior in high school. Still running currently, yesterday I ran the Hot Chocolate 5K in Asheville. My 25:26 time keep me on-par with my peers (60-65). A fifty year aged women was right behind me at the finish line. She also started running in High School. For some of us, running is apart of our self-care. In my youth, I ran everyday and needed too, but since cresting 60, running once a week is sufficient.
Yes, we all change as we age and learning to respect and surf with that change is the gift of a regular yoga practice!