If Shutdown Is Not Driven by the Dorsal Vagus, Then What Creates It?
By Kristine Kaoverii Weber | May 24, 2026

The first time I heard about Polyvagal Theory was in a workshop in Washington, D.C. I think it was 2010 or 2011. The facilitator taught us that there was a primitive part of the vagus nerve that initiated the shutdown response. Much like an animal going limp before being devoured by a predator, the "Dorsal Vagal Shutdown" was a way for humans to deal with overwhelmingly unsafe situations. If the animal is not killed, they may do some sort of shaking to bring themselves out of the state. But, since humans have socialized ourselves out of that behavior, we may need some kind of somatic technique to help us recover.
The dorsal vagal shutdown state was framed as a kindness of nature, so that mammals don't die terrified – I really liked that part of the story.
But many scientists have questioned the idea of shutdown being primarily initiated by the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus.
A recent article published by Paul Grossman and several other neurophysiologists and neuroanatomists went into elaborate detail about the problems with Polyvagal Theory. But I’m not going to write about all of them today. Here, I just want to talk about the shutdown response. And before I untangle it, the first thing I want to say is that the practices that yoga teachers, therapists, and somatic practitioners have used to help people get out of this state can be quite helpful and healing – and I think that Stephen Porges intuited something very important about how emotional states emanate from the body. But practice and theory are different things. And theories are just theories, and when they need updating...well, why hang on to them?
So, let's unpack "shutdown." When escape from a dangerous situation feels impossible, the whole system engages in a hypometabolic defense response. Brainstem circuits, particularly those involving a midbrain structure called the periaqueductal gray (PAG), may get activated and shift the system from hyperarousal (running away or fighting) to hypoarousal (shutting down) in an attempt to conserve energy.
PVT traces this state to the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus, which is why you'll hear people describing it as "Dorsal Vagal Shutdown." And while shutdown may involve vagal activity, Grossman claims that it's inadequate to describe it as a “dorsal vagal” state. His article argues that shutdown involves multiple systems including sympathetic withdrawal, blood pressure regulation, brainstem reflexes, endocrine changes, and threat circuitry. Metabolism may slow down, blood pressure may drop, and there may be some motor inhibition. Endorphins, which are the body’s endogenous opioids, may be released, as well as endocannabinoids, and there may be some endocrine-immune shifts. And yes, the vagus may participate, especially in slowing some functions down but, calling it “Dorsal Vagal Shutdown” is confusing – as if this part of the vagus nerve governs the shift. It's more accurate to think of it as a complex, global, hypometabolic and psychological state.
In shutdown, the ability to think clearly and even understand what’s going on around you may be significantly reduced, as if your mind has become molasses. There may be feelings of slowness, numbness, tiredness, flatness, fogginess, and disconnection.
I don't think I'm the only yoga teacher who, while studying trauma, was taught that the shutdown state is initiated primarily by the dorsal vagal branch of the vagus nerve, but there is a lack of scientific evidence to support this claim. And you can’t leave out psychology here; science has not fully explained how the mind is involved in the creation of this state.
So, instead of using a term like “Dorsal Vagal Shutdown,” we’d be more accurate just calling it a "shutdown state" – and if you need to go further, saying something like "a shutdown state initiated by a whole-system hypometabolic defense response" is more accurate.
BTW, shutdown is not the same as deep relaxation. It’s a survival state of metabolic conservation and it's not necessarily pleasant.

***
When I was a kid, my dad brought me with him to give blood. He lay down on a cot. A nurse inserted a needle into his arm, and then I watched the blood start to spiral through the plastic coil and into a transparent bag. I got dizzy, my eyes rolled back in my head and I started to slump. The nurse caught me, propped me up, and brought me some orange juice.
She called it “vagaling out" and joked with my dad that I probably shouldn't go into the medical field. The medical term for vagaling out is "vasovagal syncope." And though it seems similar to the shutdown state, and it certainly involves the vagus nerve, it’s actually a global reflex pattern. And, it’s not the same thing physiologically or psychologically as shutdown. I can't help but wonder if Dr. Porges saw the shorthand and thought it would be a good way to describe another state that also involves the vagus? Let me know if you have any info there.
I’m not saying Polyvagal oriented therapies aren't helpful or that the vagus nerve is irrelevant. I’m saying the phrase “dorsal vagal shutdown,” especially as it is often taught in yoga and trauma trainings, can make a complex whole-system survival response sound like it is caused by one branch of one nerve, and that’s a problem.
For yoga teachers, the practical issue is about understanding when someone might be in a shutdown state in a yoga space. The person may look calm, but if there's low affect, minimal responsiveness, blank staring, delayed following of cues, and difficulty orienting, these aren't signs of deep relaxation, they may be signs of dissociation, which I wrote about in my last blog.
Gentle grounding cues like “feel your feet,” “notice the chair beneath you,” "Take a slow look around the room," or “can you feel the temperature of the air?” can help invite the person back without overwhelming them. But these situations can also require medical attention, especially if the person is deeply disoriented.
I have heard Polyvagal oriented clinicians say that Dorsal Vagal shutdown is just a term or a name to describe more complex issues. But Polyvagal theory tends to jump between metaphor, clinical application and physiology, without warning, which is confusing for those of us who aren't scientists.
I have been and will continue to write about some of the issues with PVT here and on my Substack – I hope it's helpful for sifting through it.
Check out this 6 minute "Bed Yoga" practice - it's for anyone, but I made it specifically for folks who come to chair yoga classes, but struggled to get up and down from the floor easily (so they miss out on supine practices - but they can do this at home). Comes with Stick Figures!
CHAIR YOGA FOR YOUR BRAIN & NERVOUS SYSTEM
SUBTLE® YOGA FOR ENHANCING TRAUMA RECOVERY
Five Ways Yogic Meditation Benefits Your Brain – eBook
QUESTIONS?
We would love to hear from you!
Please wait while comments are loading...


