Escape from the YouTube Yoga Jungle
By Kristine Kaoverii Weber | March 10, 2023
A few months ago I received an email from a yoga teacher offering a class called, “Yoga for Low Back Pain.” I clicked on the link and it took me to a YouTube video which had been viewed tens of thousands of times.
Now, the first thing I’d like to say is that I’m sure this teacher has good intentions and is a nice person. Nevertheless, the video was…let’s say problematic. In fact, after watching a few minutes I couldn’t help but reflect on the irony of the title. Maybe it was a class for low back pain. As in, this class will surely give you it.
The class included Bow pose, Wheel, a couple of strong seated twists and seated forward bends. These are poses that, for many people, could very well initiate or exacerbate low back pain. (Oh, and it was also described as “yoga for beginners.”) Yup.
I decided to see how far down the YouTube low back pain yoga rabbit hole goes and so I searched for and then watched several more videos which had titles like “5 Easy Yoga Poses for Fast Low Back Pain Relief,” “7 Asanas to Relieve Back Pain Instantly,” and my personal fave, “10 Yoga Postures to Relieve Back Pain in 10 Minutes.” Yup.
Some of these videos featured people in full backbends or extreme lunges. At this point I realized that things were worse than I’d imagined.
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot people.
Now, I realize that some folks benefit from these videos. I am also well aware that there’s some good yoga content on YouTube. And YouTube is a great way to make yoga accessible to people who otherwise would not be able to get any kind of instruction. It’s also a useful resource for folks who don’t have insurance or can’t afford PT or yoga therapy.
But the problem with YouTube yoga videos, therapeutically oriented or otherwise is that, let’s be frank here, YouTube is a yoga jungle – if you don’t have an experienced guide to help you navigate it, you can easily get yourself into trouble. You may machete through that jungle, but that doesn’t mean you won’t end up more lost than when you started. How are people with no yoga, biomechanical, or medical training supposed to find solid advice on YouTube? We are living in times of excessive, often inaccurate information about yoga (and just about everything else). This can breed tremendous confusion. I don’t think it’s outrageous to assert that it’s essential to have guidance about any topic with which we are unfamiliar.
According to a recent Harris Poll, 3 out of 10 Americans live with chronic low back pain and the low back pain industry rakes in more than $100 billion a year. So yeah, there’s a lot of interest in the topic. Ka-ching.
But I think it’s important for the general public as well as every health and wellness professional to understand that being trained and experienced in teaching yoga means something. And it is a different skill than being able to do impressive yoga postures. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard someone say their doctor told them to do yoga, but said nothing about how, where, or with whom.
People with low back pain need to be evaluated by a licensed health care provider and get good advice about what movements will help and which will not. Some people will need to limit twists or forward bends, others may need to limit back bends or lateral bends. Some people need to target strengthening or mobilizing specific areas. Again, I realize the cost may be prohibitive to some, but we’re talking about the back here – it’s a health priority. YouTube is fun for podcasts and entertainment, but would you trust your teeth or your eyesight care to social media?
While the wrong yoga practice can create or exacerbate low back pain, the right yoga practice (for you) may be excellent for reducing low back pain – the trouble is finding that practice.
I’d like to offer some guidelines. These are incredibly basic, but I hope they can at least serve as landmarks pointing the way out of the most treacherous parts of the YouTube yoga jungle.
Start small – Small, mindful movements give the neuromuscular system a chance to readjust its signaling. When you start small you allow the nervous system to remain in a parasympathetic (relaxation) state. This supports the development of a kinder relationships with your back. It helps you discover what feels good and what doesn’t. Less is more. By the way, when you decide you are ready to do something about your low back pain, it can take days, weeks, months, or even years to fully understand what works and what doesn’t. There are rarely instant fixes for back pain. All good relationships require time – your relationship to your back is no different.
Start supine – For many people with low back pain (but not all) supine is the most comfortable position for movement. When you are lying flat on your back, your spine is less loaded. That means there is less compressive force pushing down into the lumbar structures. In general, less load means that movement from this position carries less risk and may be more useful. (And, as an aside, seated poses convey the most force, particularly seated and leaning forward – hence seated forwards bends and deep twists are very often contraindicated.)
Symmetry is Good – For many people with low back pain (but not all) symmetrical movements should be explored first. So simple forward bends, like Apanasana, and simple back bends like Cobra (bent elbows) and low Bridge are often safer than twists or side bends.
Find ease and comfort – When your back is uncomfortable, the most important thing is to find a position that feels stable and limits discomfort. From that position, you can begin to mindfully explore movements. There is no magic bullet yoga pose that’s going to make your back pain evaporate. Rather, the method is the mind. Pay attention to the signals from your body. Move slowly and mindfully and find what feels comfortable. Gradually, over time, expand your movements. Be consistent, practice regularly. Comfortable movement can help damp down pain signaling. Be patient. It can take time to rewire pain signaling. This learning process can transfer to your awareness of daily life movements off the mat, so that you continue the process of understanding what makes your back feel worse and what makes it feel better.
Build strength mindfully – Most people with low back pain can benefit from building muscular support. This can be a key element of reducing back pain. Working prone (on your stomach) and lifting the chest and legs in various ways to various heights can be excellent for strengthening back muscles. Also lifting the hips from supine (Bridge pose above) can be beneficial as well. Again, slow and mindful is the ticket.
Social media is here to stay and no one can police the YouTube yoga jungle. What we can do, however, is continue to educate ourselves so that we can point people out of the jungle and towards accurate information.
Next week I’ll be writing about other factors which may be involved in low back pain – hint: they are not all structural!
Save the date! Please join me for The Neuroscience of Yoga for Low Back and Hip Health. April 22, May 6, and May 20, 9:30-1:30 ET. Optional live Q and A sessions May 22, 7 pm & May 25, 12 noon. (Can’t make it all, no worries, it will be recorded). Details coming soon!
And please check out my mini course, Visioning 2023 here.
WEATHER THE STORM:
A SUBTLE® YOGA GUIDE FOR BUILDING RESILIENCE
Cultivating Calm in Times of Crisis – A Subtle® Yoga Tool Kit
Discover how to help your students get through this crisis… by gaining an incredible skill set from the comfort of your home and within a few hours!
Subtle Yoga for Greater Nervous System Resilience and Brain Function
Download my FREE Yoga class video - plus script and stick figure cheat sheet today! Try something different! Help your students focus on their nervous system, not just their hamstrings!
Stay Up To Date!
Sign up for our newsletter.
You have Successfully Subscribed!
We would love to hear from you!
Please wait while comments are loading...
Thoughtful column, thank you. There is such a need for slow, gentle, reflective teaching.
yes I believe there is.
Excellent blog post, Kristine and consistent with what I’ve learned and practiced over the years.
And, this is so true: “I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard someone say their doctor told them to do yoga, but said nothing about how, where, or with whom.” Somehow people don’t think to tell their doctor and somehow their doctor doesn’t think to ask. It’s like everybody thinks they know the full extent of yoga in one personally-held, reductive image.
Thanks Lonnie. The referral issue is a big one.
I am struggling with lower back issues. I went to a spinal doctor when it all started in my early 79ties, after examining me he sent me to a PT he would send his wife to and she is a yogi. I was so grateful for that information as he helped me.
I am and have been a certified 500 hour Kripalu teacher for 38 years, and my style had developed over the years seeing what really helps my students. I am 79 years old and hole to teach a little longer and looking forward to participating in your yoga for the lower back.
Thanks for sharing your wisdom for all these years Bodil and I’d be honored if you join me!
Great article – again !
Whisky tango fixtrot made me laugh !
I teach Yoga For Healthy Lower Backs in the UK. It’s a great course. You won’t find it on YouTube. You may have heard of it ? Founded on a research trial with 312 participants so scientifically sound.
Thanks for speaking out xx
No I haven’t heard of it, but thank you for doing solid, research based work!!!
That was so helpful
Thankyou so much for the information and guidance
Glad it’s helpful Heather!
Excellent article like a lot we are more than muscles and bones
10 poses in 10 minutes 😂. Whiskey Tango Foxtrot…thanks for the giggles this morning. Seriously though…great points. As a retired PT, knowing the cause of the back pain makes all the difference. Extension moves for degenerative disc disease would be no bueno as would loaded spinal flexion for a herniated disc.
Thanks for your input Brenda. I can imagine that, as a PT, it’s hard to inhibit the eye rolling when it comes to popular asana practice.🙄
As always, spot on. Thank you Kristine.
As always, well spoken and well researched… Thanks for being a voice of reason and HEART. God Bless!
What a great read this is. Lapping it up and looking forward to this upcoming class!