Anatomy Schmalatomy

By Kristine Kaoverii Weber | August 24, 2024

COMMENTS

a drawing of a woman in a yoga pose showing her muscles

Recently I was talking to a yoga teacher who said that she was feeling a little insecure about her anatomy knowledge. Now, this isn’t a new teacher, it wasn’t someone who recently graduated with only 20 hours of anatomy study. It was a person who’s been teaching and studying for quite a while - she’s a good teacher.

My eyebrows went all Botoxy.

You!? I said. Are you kidding me? Anatomy Shmalatomy. Since when did the primary knowledge base for teaching yoga become anatomy?

She told me she's been seeing so much out there lately about how yoga teachers are terrible at anatomy and biomechanics and it made her feel insecure and like she needed to learn more. Of course anatomy and biomechanics are important topics for yoga teachers to understand, and you want to feel competent and confident in what and how you’re teaching, but, personally, I didn’t become a yoga teacher because I wanted to teach people to differentiate the nuances of their three hamstrings.

I became a yoga teacher because yoga changed my life. It helped me overcome depression and an eating disorder. It helped me find a deeper sense of meaning and purpose in my life. I became a yoga teacher because I wanted to help others find balance and peace. I became a yoga teacher because I’m fascinated by the human experience – mind, body, spirit – and yoga gave me a framework through which to explore it.

a drawing of a woman in childs pose. decorated with flowers

There’s been a bias in the western yoga world for quite some time that positions the study of anatomy above all other aspects of yoga study. I think this is because the western worldview approaches life through the lens of reductionism and scientific materialism. We tend to want to break things down, analyze them, and understand the components. We want to reduce the human experience to what we can observe and measure. Since the body is what we can see, it follows that most of a yoga teacher’s studying time, energy, and resources should be spent learning anatomy.

Perhaps it’s also because of the equation that good yoga teaching = mastering hard poses. If you want to become a master teacher, then you obviously need to practice advanced asanas, and you need to be able to demonstrate them effortlessly. You should want your students to be able to achieve and accomplish these poses too, and you want them to do that safely, and the building blocks of all of these goals is a masterful grasp of anatomy and biomechanics.

But what if hard poses and/or perfect biomechanics are not your goal? What if you prefer teaching people how to slow down, self-regulate, develop greater interoceptive awareness, feel more comfortable in their own skin, learn to love themselves, learn to connect with themselves, understand their minds, and learn to develop a more intimate relationship with spirit?

What if keeping your students safe is not a huge issue for you because you are not teaching anything that’s terribly risky to begin with? And what if anatomy isn’t the most interesting part of studying and teaching yoga?

BTW, if you love anatomy and can’t get enough of the stuff, more power to you. For some people anatomy is a fascinating course of study and since our standards for teaching are pretty low, I think every yoga teacher needs a basic grasp of these topics. And anatomy is an essential knowledge base if you are also an anatomist, a PT, an orthopedist, a chiropractor, a fascia researcher, etc.

But if you are a yoga teacher with a basic grasp of anatomy and biomechanics, I would argue that it makes sense to broaden your perspective and your knowledge base and explore other landscapes in the wide world of yoga.

a drawing of a woman in a yoga pose showing her muscles

Yoga teachers may find that they really love studying Sanskrit, Ayurveda, yoga cosmology, epistemology, ethics, or ontology. Some may be interested in yogic and Vedic models of the mind, the history of yoga, western psychology, the autonomic nervous system, neuroscience, mudras, meditation, pranayama, subtle anatomy, and more. All of these are relevant, pertinent, and practical for the teaching of yoga. And every one of these topics is just as vast and useful as the study of anatomy.

This is one of the reasons I love yoga so much: it’s never boring, there’s always so much more to learn – so why reduce it to anatomy and biomechanics?

And just to be clear, I don’t think all yoga teachers need to become experts in any of these topics. But I also don’t think that every yoga teacher needs a PhD in anatomy.  

Yoga is largely experiential.  It involves learning to turn off your categorizing, analytical mind and tune into a deeper wisdom and knowing. It involves learning to feel into your body, and beyond your body into your subtle body, and the deeper levels of mind. It also, importantly, involves tuning into and experiencing the wisdom of your higher self. These skills have intrinsic value that is at least as important, if not more so, than understanding what each muscle, bone, and joint is doing in a pose.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not throwing anatomy under the bus, but if you became a yoga teacher to learn and teach anatomy and biomechanics, perhaps you made a mistake. Perhaps you should've become a chiropractor or a physical therapist instead. Either profession certainly pays better.

LMK what your thoughts in the comments.

 

I’ll be teaching a workshop in October called "Somatic Subtle Body Yoga" – I’d love you to consider joining me. Please keep an eye out for an email with details on Monday.

CHAIR YOGA FOR YOUR BRAIN & NERVOUS SYSTEM

SUBTLE® YOGA FOR ENHANCING TRAUMA RECOVERY

Five Ways Yogic Meditation Benefits Your Brain – eBook

QUESTIONS?

We would love to hear from you!

    Please wait while comments are loading...

    SUBTLE YOGA HAS SO MUCH TO OFFER!

    Sign up for updates, events, and blog.

    You have Successfully Subscribed!